Social Links Widget

Click here to edit the Social Media Links settings. This text will not be visible on the front end.

closed sales • Condominiums • dry lot homes • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Housing Market • Market Data • MLS • New Year • real estate market • Sales • single family homes • sold properties • waterfront • February 7, 2025

Florida Keys Real Estate: January 2024 vs. January 2025 Market Trends

by Tracy Larson

As we enter 2025, the Florida Keys real estate market continues to evolve. A year-over-year comparison of January 2024 and January 2025 data provides key insights into shifting trends in home sales, pricing, and market activity across single-family homes and condos throughout the region.

Single-Family Homes: Higher Prices, Fewer Sales, and Longer Market Times

Open Water Homes

  • January 2024: 15 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $2,234,533 | Days on Market: 67
  • January 2025: 9 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $3,242,955 | Days on Market: 101

Market Insight: Open water homes saw a significant price jump of over $1 million on average, but fewer properties sold, and the time on market increased by over a month, indicating a more selective buyer pool.

Canalfront Homes

  • January 2024: 35 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $1,843,031 | Days on Market: 61
  • January 2025: 26 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $1,339,019 | Days on Market: 85

Market Insight: Canalfront homes experienced a notable decrease in both sales volume and average price, with homes staying on the market longer. This could indicate buyers becoming more cautious about investment costs.

Non-Waterfront Homes

  • January 2024: 32 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $1,227,031 | Days on Market: 81
  • January 2025: 33 homes sold | Average Sales Price: $1,354,242 | Days on Market: 83

Market Insight: While the number of non-waterfront homes sold remained stable, there was a modest price increase, suggesting that affordability and location continue to drive buyer interest.

Condos, Townhomes, and Condo-Tels: Market Adjustments

Waterfront View Properties

  • January 2024: 19 units sold | Average Sales Price: $1,035,052 | Days on Market: 51
  • January 2025: 15 units sold | Average Sales Price: $1,013,666 | Days on Market: 105

Market Insight: Waterfront view condo sales declined, and properties are taking longer to sell, pointing to a more cautious buyer approach despite relatively stable pricing.

Non-Waterfront View Properties

  • January 2024: 18 units sold | Average Sales Price: $834,166 | Days on Market: 70
  • January 2025: 6 units sold | Average Sales Price: $573,750 | Days on Market: 33

Market Insight: The non-waterfront condo market saw a drastic decline in sales and a significant drop in pricing, making it a potential opportunity for bargain buyers but a concern for sellers.

Key Takeaways for Buyers and Sellers

  • Sellers: The market is shifting, and pricing strategically is key. While open water homes command premium prices, other segments, particularly condos, are seeing softer demand.
  • Buyers: Opportunities exist in the condo market, where prices are down and market times are up, allowing for negotiation power.
  • Investors: With longer market times, now may be a good time to identify properties with strong long-term value and potential appreciation.

As always, understanding the latest market trends is crucial when making real estate decisions in the Florida Keys. Whether you’re buying or selling, staying informed ensures you’re making the most of market conditions.

 

All data from The Florida Keys Board of Realtors Multiple Listing Service – Flex MLS.  Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. 

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • new listings • property for sale • real estate • February 3, 2025

94 New Listings Hit the Market in the Florida Keys: A Glimpse into Island Living

by Tracy Larson

The Florida Keys are no stranger to the allure of sun-kissed shores, turquoise waters, and an easy-going island lifestyle, but the real estate market is catching an exciting breeze right now. With 94 new listings recently hitting the market, there’s never been a better time to explore what makes living in this paradise so special.

The New Listings: A Snapshot

As of this week, 94 fresh properties have entered the market across the Florida Keys, offering a variety of options for those looking to make this island chain their home. From charming cottages tucked away in tropical foliage to luxurious waterfront estates with private docks, these new listings cater to diverse tastes and budgets. The properties span across several islands in the Keys, from Key Largo all the way down to Key West, each with its own unique vibe and appeal.

  • Key Largo: Often referred to as the “Diving Capital of the World,” this northernmost island has several listings that combine easy access to both nature and luxury. Whether you’re looking for a canal-front home with a boat dock or a cozy retreat nestled in the Everglades National Park, Key Largo offers endless adventure at your doorstep.
  • Islamorada: Known for its world-class fishing and vibrant arts scene, Islamorada’s new listings include oceanfront homes that feel like your private paradise. Picture yourself living in a sprawling estate with sweeping ocean views or a stylish townhome just a short boat ride from the island’s best reefs.
  • Marathon: Often considered the heart of the Keys, Marathon is home to a variety of mid-range homes that provide access to both the Atlantic Ocean and Gulf of Mexico. New listings here include canal-side homes and private villas, offering a perfect blend of convenience and seclusion.
  • Lower Keys & Key West: The charm of the Lower Keys and the excitement of Key West never go out of style. Newly listed properties range from classic conch-style homes to modern beachside condos. Key West, in particular, offers a unique blend of history, culture, and nightlife, with homes located in the heart of Old Town or more secluded spots near Smathers Beach.

Why Island Living in the Florida Keys?

Living in the Florida Keys is unlike any other place in the U.S. The island lifestyle offers a laid-back atmosphere, warm weather year-round, and a strong sense of community. Here’s a look at some of the perks of calling the Keys home:

1. Natural Beauty at Your Doorstep

The Florida Keys are known for their stunning natural landscapes. From the coral reefs just off the coast to the lush mangroves, the Keys are a paradise for nature lovers. Whether you enjoy snorkeling, kayaking, fishing, or simply lounging on the beach, island living places you in the heart of it all. The turquoise waters and vibrant sunsets never get old.

2. The Great Outdoors Year-Round

Thanks to the Keys’ tropical climate, outdoor activities are available year-round. Imagine waking up to a morning kayak ride through crystal-clear waters, or spending an afternoon fishing along the shore with friends. Because the weather remains warm throughout the year, the Florida Keys offer a true outdoor lifestyle, perfect for those who love being active and enjoying the beauty of nature.

3. Tight-Knit Island Community

While the Florida Keys are a top tourist destination, the people who live here tend to form tight-knit, welcoming communities. Life is a little slower here, and that fosters meaningful connections. Whether you’re dining at a local seafood spot or attending one of the many events that take place throughout the year, you’ll quickly find that the people of the Keys are as warm and welcoming as the climate.

4. The Culture and Art Scene

Each of the Keys has its own distinctive personality, but they all share an appreciation for art, history, and local culture. Key West, for example, has a thriving arts scene, with galleries, museums, and theaters that showcase the work of both local and international artists. The annual Hemingway Days Festival draws fans of the legendary author from all over the world, and Islamorada’s relaxed, bohemian vibe makes it the perfect setting for art shows and cultural events.

5. Fishing, Boating, and Watersports

For those who enjoy life on the water, the Florida Keys are unbeatable. With the Atlantic Ocean on one side and the Gulf of Mexico on the other, island residents have access to world-class fishing, boating, and water sports. Whether you’re into deep-sea fishing, fly fishing in the backcountry, or sailing to nearby islands for a day trip, the Keys have everything you need to indulge your love of the water.

Is Island Living Right for You?

While living in the Florida Keys sounds like a dream to many, it’s important to consider your lifestyle and preferences. The islands offer a unique mix of convenience and seclusion. There are world-class amenities, but the pace of life is slower, and access to some services might be limited compared to mainland areas. In addition, the Florida Keys are known for being a bit more expensive than other parts of Florida, particularly when it comes to real estate.

That said, for those who are drawn to the beauty, serenity, and charm of the islands, the Florida Keys can feel like a permanent vacation. Whether you’re retiring to your dream home, seeking adventure in the great outdoors, or simply escaping the hustle and bustle of city life, the Florida Keys offer an unparalleled lifestyle.

Conclusion

With 94 new listings now on the market, there are fresh opportunities for those interested in making the Florida Keys their home. Whether you’re seeking a luxurious oceanfront estate or a cozy getaway tucked between the trees, island living in the Keys is as enchanting as it is unique. From natural beauty to outdoor activities and a vibrant community, there’s something for everyone on these sun-soaked islands. Don’t miss out—your island paradise awaits.

Ready to explore? Click here to see if any of the new listings are perfect for you!

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Homes for Sale • Island Living • Key West • Luxury Estates • Luxury Homes • Open Water • Open Water Views • real estate • Shark Key • January 31, 2025

Luxury Waterfront Living on Shark Key, Florida Keys

by Tracy Larson

Nestled just 11 miles from the vibrant energy of Key West, Shark Key offers an unparalleled level of privacy and exclusivity. This gated island community is home to a collection of luxury waterfront estates, each designed to capture the essence of upscale tropical living.

Shark Key is more than just a place to live—it’s a private retreat surrounded by turquoise waters and breathtaking sunset views. Residents enjoy access to pristine white sand beaches, a clubhouse, tennis courts, and a serene lagoon perfect for paddleboarding or kayaking. With expansive lots and custom-built homes, this enclave is designed for those seeking elegance, tranquility, and premier waterfront living.

Despite its secluded feel, Shark Key is just minutes from world-class dining, shopping, and entertainment in Key West, providing the best of both worlds—peaceful island seclusion with easy access to city conveniences. Whether you’re looking for a permanent residence or a vacation getaway, Shark Key offers a rare opportunity to own a slice of paradise in the Florida Keys.

If you’re dreaming of luxury waterfront living in the Keys, Shark Key is an extraordinary place to call home.

Click here to see the current listings on Shark Key

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
above flood • below flood • buyers • buying advice • Florida Keys Real Estate • Home Buying • Housing Market • pre-firm • Remodeling • sellers • January 28, 2025

Understanding Legal Non-Conforming Properties in the Florida Keys: What Buyers and Sellers Need to Know

by Tracy Larson

In the Florida Keys real estate market, “legal non-conforming” refers to a property, structure, or use that was legally established under previous zoning or land-use regulations but does not conform to current rules. This designation allows the property to continue being used as it is, despite changes in local codes or regulations, as long as it remains in compliance with specific conditions.

Key Points About Legal Non-Conforming Properties:

  1. Grandfathered Status: The property is “grandfathered” under the older regulations that were in place when it was built or established.
    • Example: A home built closer to the waterline than current setbacks allow.
  2. Usage Continuity: The non-conforming use is usually allowed to continue as long as it is not abandoned, significantly altered, or replaced.
    • Example: A small vacation rental operating in an area where short-term rentals are no longer permitted.
  3. Limited Expansion or Reconstruction: Regulations often prohibit the expansion or rebuilding of legal non-conforming properties beyond their original footprint or size.
    • Example: If a legal non-conforming stilt home is destroyed by a hurricane, rebuilding it to the same specifications may not be allowed.
  4. Environmental Regulations: In the Keys, legal non-conforming properties are often tied to strict environmental protections, such as setbacks from mangroves, waterways, or wetlands.
  5. ROGO Considerations: If a legal non-conforming property requires major updates or changes, it may need to comply with the Florida Keys’ Rate of Growth Ordinance (ROGO), which regulates development rights.
  6. Transferability: The non-conforming status typically stays with the property and transfers to new owners, provided the use remains consistent and complies with conditions outlined by local authorities.

Why It Matters:

Legal non-conforming properties are common in the Florida Keys due to evolving environmental and building codes, especially as the area has heightened focus on protecting ecosystems and adapting to flood risks. Buyers and sellers must carefully evaluate these properties, often requiring guidance from legal or zoning experts to understand the implications for future use, renovations, or insurance.

If you’d like, I can provide specific examples or help clarify how this could impact a real estate transaction!

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Home Buying • Islamorada • Key Largo • new listings • real estate • January 27, 2025

Florida Keys Real Estate Season Is In Full Swing with 78 New Listings on the Market!

by Tracy Larson

The Florida Keys real estate market is buzzing with activity as 78 fresh listings hit the market, offering buyers a diverse range of properties to choose from. Whether you’re looking for a cozy condo or an opulent waterfront estate, there’s something to suit every taste and budget.

A Property for Every Lifestyle

The new listings start at an attractive $329,000 for condos that deliver an affordable slice of paradise. These units are perfect for first-time buyers, snowbirds, or those seeking a low-maintenance getaway. On the other end of the spectrum are breathtaking estates priced at up to $17,000,000, showcasing unparalleled luxury. These magnificent homes boast features such as private docks, panoramic ocean views, infinity pools, and state-of-the-art finishes—ideal for buyers seeking the pinnacle of coastal living.

The Selling Season is in Full Swing

Winter months often mark the height of selling season in the Florida Keys, as seasonal residents, vacationers, and investors descend upon the area. This influx creates a vibrant market where properties are moving fast. The warm weather, crystal-clear waters, and unmatched island lifestyle draw attention from around the globe, making now the ideal time for both buyers and sellers to act.

Market Trends and Buyer Opportunities

With the market heating up, buyers are encouraged to act swiftly. Inventory is moving quickly due to strong demand, particularly for waterfront properties with boating access and vacation rental potential. Sellers, meanwhile, are benefiting from high buyer interest, which is driving competitive offers.

Whether you’re looking to invest, relocate, or find your dream home, this new wave of listings provides the perfect opportunity to make your move. Contact your trusted real estate professional to explore the latest offerings and secure your place in the Florida Keys lifestyle.

Don’t wait too long—the Keys’ unique charm and competitive market make these properties highly desirable. Dive into this exciting season and discover your piece of paradise today!

Click here to view the list of new properties. 

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
Condominiums • Dockage • Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Investment • Moon Bay • January 24, 2025

Moon Bay Condominiums: A Key Largo Treasure with Unmatched Amenities and Investment Potential

by Tracy Larson

Moon Bay Condominiums in Key Largo is a gated waterfront community on the serene Florida Bay, offering a perfect mix of tropical relaxation and investment opportunity. With its weekly rental policy, Moon Bay is ideal for investors or those seeking passive income. Enjoy it as your private retreat or earn income by renting it out when you’re away.

Currently listed at $975,000, Unit A501 is a standout offering in the community. This updated, fully furnished corner-end unit boasts unparalleled bay views and a screened balcony, perfect for enjoying stunning Florida Keys sunsets. Included with the unit is a deeded 30 ft. boat slip (#63) with a boat lift—perfect for avid boaters ready to explore the pristine waters of the Keys.

Moon Bay isn’t just about the views; it’s about the lifestyle. Residents enjoy a wealth of amenities, including:

  • A refreshing heated pool with a spacious sun deck.
  • A clubhouse complete with a kitchen and lounge for entertaining.
  • Tennis courts for a friendly match or some exercise.
  • A private marina for easy boating access.
  • Fishing docks for enjoying peaceful mornings on the water.
  • A BBQ and picnic area, ideal for outdoor gatherings with family and friends.
  • A game room and saunas, adding extra comfort and recreation options.

Conveniently located just an hour from Miami, Moon Bay offers the best of both worlds: a peaceful escape and easy access to Miami International Airport, PortMiami for cruises, and all the city’s attractions.

Don’t miss your chance to own Unit A501 at Moon Bay Condominiums—a beautiful property that combines luxury, convenience, and income potential in the heart of the Florida Keys!

Click here to view the details for unit A501

Listing provide courtesy of Diana Lynn Fiddes, Coldwell Banker Schmitt 

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
above flood • below flood • buying advice • fema • flood insurance • flood insurance reform • flood zones • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • January 23, 2025

Understanding “Above Flood” vs. “Below Flood” Homes in the Florida Keys

by Tracy Larson

When buying or selling a home in the Florida Keys, one of the most significant factors to consider is whether a property is “above flood” or “below flood.” This distinction doesn’t just impact the structure of the home—it also plays a crucial role in determining insurance costs and resale value.

What Does “Above Flood” and “Below Flood” Mean?

The terms “above flood” and “below flood” refer to the home’s elevation in relation to the Base Flood Elevation (BFE). The BFE is determined by FEMA and indicates the minimum height to which floodwaters are expected to rise during a 100-year flood event.

  • Above Flood: Homes built above the BFE are considered safer from flood risks. These properties are often elevated on stilts, pilings, or built on fill, ensuring the living space is higher than potential floodwaters.
  • Below Flood: Homes below the BFE are more vulnerable to flooding, as their living areas sit at or below the expected floodwater levels.

Insurance Implications

Flood insurance is a critical consideration for any property in the Florida Keys due to the area’s susceptibility to hurricanes and rising sea levels. The elevation of a home directly impacts flood insurance premiums:

  • Above Flood Homes: These homes typically qualify for lower flood insurance premiums because their design reduces the risk of water damage. Owners often save significantly on annual insurance costs, making these properties highly desirable.
  • Below Flood Homes: Homes below the BFE face higher flood risks, resulting in substantially higher insurance premiums. Additionally, obtaining coverage may be more challenging, especially for older properties not built to current FEMA standards.

Market Value and Resale Considerations

  • Above Flood Homes: Due to their lower insurance costs and compliance with modern building codes, above-flood homes are often more attractive to buyers and can command higher resale values.
  • Below Flood Homes: While these homes may initially be more affordable, the higher cost of flood insurance and potential flood damage risks can deter buyers, impacting long-term value.

Key Takeaways for Buyers and Sellers

  1. Know the Elevation Certificate: Whether buying or selling, obtaining the property’s elevation certificate is essential to understanding its flood zone and insurance implications.
  2. Factor in Insurance Costs: Buyers should account for flood insurance premiums in their budgeting, while sellers should highlight any flood mitigation features to attract buyers.
  3. Consider Future Resilience: With rising sea levels and stricter building codes, properties that are above flood may offer better long-term value and peace of mind.

Navigating the nuances of “above flood” and “below flood” homes in the Florida Keys requires expertise. As a seasoned real estate professional with decades of experience in the region, I’m here to help you make informed decisions that protect your investment and fit your lifestyle.

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
Buying • buying advice • Condominiums • Distressed Property • Fixer Upper • Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Islamorada • Key Largo • property for sale • January 22, 2025

Discovering Hidden Gems: Purchasing a Home in the Florida Keys for Under $500,000

by Tracy Larson

When many people think of the Florida Keys, images of luxury waterfront estates and million-dollar views often come to mind. While it’s true that the Keys are home to some of the most coveted real estate in the country, there’s a common misconception that owning property here under $500,000 is out of reach. However, with the right approach, it’s entirely possible to find your slice of paradise within this budget.

Why the Florida Keys?

Living in the Keys offers an unparalleled lifestyle. From breathtaking sunsets and world-class fishing to a strong sense of community and year-round warm weather, the allure is undeniable. But beyond the dream-like appeal, the area also boasts excellent schools, convenient shopping, and a range of outdoor activities.

Opportunities Under $500,000

While the high-end real estate market often dominates the headlines, there are hidden gems available in the Florida Keys for buyers with a budget of $500,000 or less. Here’s how:

  1. Exploring Off-Water Properties
    While waterfront homes may command premium prices, inland properties and those located on canals or off the beaten path can be surprisingly affordable. These homes still offer the charm and proximity to the ocean without the waterfront premium.
  2. Condos and Townhomes
    The Keys have a variety of condo and townhouse communities that provide an affordable entry point. Many offer amenities like pools, marinas, and maintenance-free living, making them an excellent choice for first-time buyers or those seeking a vacation home.
  3. Fixer-Uppers
    If you’re open to a little elbow grease, a fixer-upper could be the way to go. Renovating a home allows you to customize it to your tastes while potentially building equity.
  4. Key Largo and Beyond
    While Key West often garners the most attention, areas like Key Largo, Marathon, and Big Pine Key offer more budget-friendly options. These communities provide a quieter pace of life while still delivering that coveted Keys lifestyle.

Insider Tips for Finding Affordable Homes

  • Work with a Local Expert: A real estate professional who knows the Keys can help you identify opportunities that align with your budget and goals.
  • Stay Open-Minded: Expanding your search criteria, such as considering smaller homes, older properties, or different neighborhoods, can reveal unexpected options.
  • Act Quickly: Properties in this price range are often in high demand. Being pre-approved for a mortgage and ready to make an offer can give you a competitive edge.
  • Leverage Local Knowledge: Targeted mailing lists and local market connections can uncover off-market properties or those about to be listed.

A Dream Worth Pursuing

Buying a home in the Florida Keys for under $500,000 might require creativity and flexibility, but it’s far from impossible. With a little patience and the right guidance, you can find your dream home and start living the island life you’ve always wanted.

Whether you’re seeking a full-time residence, a vacation getaway, or an investment property, there’s something magical about calling the Keys home—and that magic is accessible to more people than you might think.

If you’re ready to start exploring the possibilities, reach out today to discuss your goals. Let’s find your piece of paradise together! Click here to see a list of properties under $500,000 in the Florida Keys.

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
buying advice • Construction • Florida Keys Real Estate • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Hurricane Irma • Hurricane Recovery • hurricanes • Metal Roofing • real estate market • January 21, 2025

The Resilience of Metal: A Hurricane’s Test in the Florida Keys

by Tracy Larson

When Hurricane Irma roared through the Florida Keys in September 2017, it left behind a trail of devastation. The storm, one of the most powerful hurricanes on record, tore through the archipelago, battering homes and businesses with torrential rains, gusting winds of over 130 miles per hour, and storm surges that submerged entire islands. But amidst the destruction, one feature stood out for its remarkable resilience: metal roofs.

For years, metal roofs had been regarded by some as an alternative, more durable option to traditional shingle roofs, but it was during Hurricane Irma that the true value of this roofing choice came to light. As the storm began to approach, many residents in the Florida Keys, both full-time residents and seasonal homeowners, braced themselves for the worst. Thousands of homes had traditional asphalt shingle roofs—relatively inexpensive and widely used—but those roofs would face the ultimate test against the fury of a Category 4 hurricane.

The Challenge of Shingles

Shingle roofs, though common, have a significant weakness when faced with high winds. In Irma’s extreme conditions, these roofs struggled to hold up. The sustained winds and gusts tore at shingles, ripping them away in large sections. Once the shingles were torn off, the underlying roofing material, usually plywood or OSB, was left exposed to the elements. Rain poured in, causing significant water damage to ceilings, insulation, and walls.

In many cases, the damage was immediate and catastrophic. The loss of shingles didn’t just result in leaks; it compromised the entire integrity of the home. For many homes in the Keys, replacing a shingle roof meant starting from scratch, stripping away what was left, and rebuilding entirely.

The Strength of Metal

Meanwhile, homes with metal roofs stood in stark contrast. Though not invincible, metal roofs were far more resilient to the intense winds that came with Hurricane Irma. Metal roofs, particularly those made from standing seam panels, are designed to be highly durable, able to resist uplift and deformation under extreme wind conditions. With their interlocking panels and fasteners, metal roofs remain intact much better than their shingle counterparts, especially when the winds start to gust past 100 miles per hour.

For the homeowners who had invested in metal roofing, the experience of Hurricane Irma was notably different. While debris and damage to other parts of their homes were still significant, the roofs themselves often emerged largely unscathed. The metal did not blow off. The interlocking panels held tight, and while a few dents might have been visible from windblown debris, the roof remained intact, protecting the structure underneath.

One resident of Marathon, a small island city in the Keys, recalled how, after the storm passed, she walked out to survey the damage to her home. “I couldn’t believe it,” she said. “The roof was still there, as solid as ever. No leaks, no missing shingles. I could see homes just down the street with entire roofs gone. I was so grateful I chose metal.”

Post-Storm Comparison

In the aftermath of the hurricane, contractors and insurance adjusters quickly noticed the difference. Homes with metal roofs required far less attention and repair. Many of the homes with shingle roofs needed to be completely reroofed, which meant not just replacing the shingles but also repairing water-damaged interiors. In contrast, homes with metal roofs only required minor repairs, such as fixing a few minor dings or replacing small sections of trim or flashing that had been damaged.

Insurance companies also took notice of the stark contrast in damages. While claims for homes with shingle roofs were higher due to the need for extensive repairs, homes with metal roofs saw far fewer claims for roof damage. In the long term, this would lead to lower premiums for metal-roofed homes in hurricane-prone areas, as insurers began to see the value of a more durable roofing option.

The New Norm?

In the years following Hurricane Irma, the trend toward metal roofing has only grown in the Florida Keys and other coastal regions. Contractors report a steady increase in demand for metal roofing, as homeowners seek a more secure way to protect their properties from the inevitable hurricanes. Local building codes, already stringent in the Keys, have also begun to favor metal roofs for their durability and storm-resistance.

While the cost of metal roofing remains higher than that of asphalt shingles, many residents now see the investment as one that pays off in the long run. After all, the destruction caused by a hurricane can be devastating, but knowing your home’s roof will hold up against the fiercest winds provides a peace of mind that no shingle roof can match.

In the Florida Keys, where hurricanes are a part of life, metal roofs have proven that they are not just a choice—they’re a life-saving investment.

Related Articles
buyers market Are We Seeing a Shift in the Florida Keys Real Estate Market? For years, the Florida Keys real estate market has followed predictable seasonal trends, with the winter and early spring months bringing an influx of new listings as sellers look to take advantage of high demand. However, this year, something feels a little different. If you’ve been watching the market closely, you may have noticed that […]
buying advice Florida Real Estate and Rising Insurance Costs: What Homeowners Need to Know Home insurance costs in Florida are skyrocketing, creating major challenges for homeowners and buyers alike. As insurance rates climb, they impact affordability, property values, and the overall housing market. Why Are Insurance Rates So High? Florida homeowners now pay an average of $5,531 per year for $300,000 in dwelling coverage—142% higher than the national average. […]
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
above flood • Canalfront • Concrete Construction • Florida Keys • Florida Keys Real Estate Market • Home For Sale • Islamorada • Just Reduced • waterfront • January 20, 2025

More for Less in Islamorada! – Just Reduced and Ready for New Owners!

by Tracy Larson

Discover your dream home in Indian Waterways! This 3-bedroom, 3-bath beauty offers everything you need for the ultimate Florida Keys lifestyle:

  • Solid Masonry Construction with a poured roof for durability.
  • Impact Doors and Windows for storm protection and peace of mind.
  • Fresh Updates: New AC, modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and washer/dryer.
  • Ample Storage: A spacious 12×11 laundry/storage room and a separate storage building.
  • Boater’s Paradise: 34 ft. of concrete dock with a 10,000 lb lift for your vessel.
  • Outdoor Entertaining: A massive 16×20 chickee hut, a covered 30×12 patio area, and a screen-enclosed balcony with a walk-around deck.
  • Stylish Interior: Floating laminate floors throughout for a clean, cohesive look.
  • Fully Fenced Yard with 3 gates, offering privacy and convenience.

Located on Plantation Key, this home is part of a welcoming community with a boat ramp and park available for a modest annual fee. Plus, it’s just minutes from shopping, dining, top-rated schools, medical facilities, Founders Park, marinas, and fishing and diving charters.

203 Mohawk Street isn’t just a house—it’s a lifestyle. Come see this Keys charmer for yourself and imagine all it has to offer! 🏡 🌴

Listing provided courtesy of Keith Allen, Century 21 Circle ~ 305-481-5544

Related Articles
Concrete Construction Island Living at Its Best: Stunning Canal-Front Home with Pool, Dockage, and Storm-Resistant Concrete Construction in Islamorada Located in the highly sought-after Indian Waterways subdivision in Islamorada, Florida, 254 Navajo Street offers the ultimate in Florida Keys living. Situated on a free-flowing canal just off the Bay of America, this home is only a short ride to the Ocean via Tavernier Creek or Snake Creek. Whether you enjoy fishing, diving, or paddleboarding, […]
buying advice 71 New Listings in the Florida Keys Last Week – What’s Holding Some Sellers Back? Last week, 71 new real estate listings hit the market in the Florida Keys. While that’s still a solid number, it’s slightly lower than in previous weeks—especially considering we’re in the middle of our peak selling season. So, why might some homeowners be hesitant to list right now? A few key factors could be at […]
Buying New Construction Homes in the Florida Keys: Modern, Strong, and Built to Last Buying a home in the Florida Keys is an exciting step toward island living. While older homes offer charm, new construction homes come with major advantages. They follow stronger building codes, offer modern features, and require less maintenance, making them a smart investment for homeowners. Why Choose a New Construction Home? New homes in the […]
Home
Properties
About Me
Blog
Neighborhood News
eho-89x83.png
realtor_white-71x83.png

Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility Statement | Fair Housing Notice

© 2025 MoxiWorks

© CENTURY 21 2023 - 2024. All rights reserved. CENTURY 21®, C21® and the CENTURY 21 Logo are registered service marks owned by Century 21 Real Estate LLC. Franchisee Legal Entity Name (not the dba) fully supports the principles of the Fair Housing Act and the Equal Opportunity Act. Each franchise is independently owned and operated. Any services or products provided by independently owned and operated franchisees are not provided by, affiliated with, or related to Century 21 Real Estate LLC nor any of its affiliated companies.