Cook’s Island – True Island living in the Florida Keys

When most people think about buying property in the Florida Keys, they imagine life on a tropical island connected to the mainland by a network of bridges. Often, you can forget you’re even on an island.

But what about life on a truly remote island—no bridges, roads, phone lines, or power lines? Cook’s Island, located just off the southern tip of Big Pine Key, offers exactly that experience. Settled by Captain Percy Cook in 1923, this 67-acre island captures the spirit of the original Keys lifestyle in a rustic yet sensitively developed setting. Homes here are built with eco-friendly systems, relying on solar power and rainwater collection to meet everyday needs, and are accessible only by boat.

Outdoor adventures like kayaking, fishing, and snorkeling await right outside your door, with vibrant reefs just offshore. The beautiful beach of Bahia Honda is only a short boat ride away, and the island’s untouched environment is a paradise for nature lovers, with Key Deer and other wildlife making it their home.

Click here to see available listings